×

Successful Challenge to Police Retention of a Child’s Criminal Record

Published:

Anete Lusina via UnSplash

The High Court has handed down an important judgment on the retention of police records and the role of the Home Office’s Crime Recording Rules (the HOCR) and College of Policing’s Authorised Professional Practice guidance on Review, Retention and Disposal (the Guidance) in retention/deletion decisions: (R (DMP) v Chief Constable of Warwickshire Police [2026] EWHC 2471 (Admin)).

The Claimant has severe autism, ADHD and a number of other disabilities. When he was 8 years old he had an autistic meltdown and his behaviour led to an adult making a criminal complaint to Warwickshire Police. While no further action was taken owing, not least, to his being below the age of criminal responsibility, the police created a crime record on the Claimant, which recorded an allegation of ABH. The police refused to delete this record and indicated that they would retain it for a minimum of 10 years, purportedly in reliance on the HOCR and the Guidance.

The Claimant challenged this decision as (a) being based on a misapplication of the HOCR and APP Guidance, (b) in breach of his rights under Article 8 ECHR, (c) a discrimination arising from disability, contrary to s15 of the Equality Act 2010 (EqA), and (d) as being irrational as a matter of process and outcome owing to its being based on a conclusion that he had a capacity to inflict serious harm. HHJ Rawlings allowed the claim and ordered that the record be deleted from local records and the Police National Database.

The judgment contains important guidance on the proper effect of the HOCR. It confirms that the HOCR is primarily concerned with the generation of crime statistics and it does not require police to create or retain records in respect of named individuals. The deletion of police records (in local or national databases) and the “cancellation” of crimes for the purposes of the HOCR are discrete processes. The HOCR does not, therefore, bear on decisions to retain/delete police records. Further, when considering whether to delete/retain the Guidance demands, the judgment stresses, that police consider carefully an individual’s circumstances, particularly if they are a child.

This appears to be among the first judgments in which the courts have recognised that the retention of police records arising from behaviours connected to a person’s disability may constitute discrimination arising from disability (contrary to s15 of the EqA), where the police have not properly considered disability as part of their decision-making and do not adduce evidence sufficient to discharge the burden of justification.

Aidan Wills acted for the Claimant, instructed by Chris Stevens of CJS Defence Ltd.