Nicklin J has dismissed a CPR Part 8 claim brought by a public figure seeking an injunction against Independent Television News and The Guardian.
The two media outlets had conducted a joint investigation into allegations of sexual misconduct by the claimant. They were proposing, respectively, to broadcast a documentary and publish an article about the allegations. Their publications were to include contributions from women sources of the journalists discussing their experiences with the Claimant.
The Claimant was notified of the allegations and invited to comment. His case was that the prospect of the publications caused a serious deterioration in his mental health, including attempts to take his own life and psychiatric treatment. By his Part 8 claim he sought to prevent publication.
The Claimant contended that publication would be incompatible with the protections afforded to him by Articles, 2, 3 and 8 of the Convention.
By agreement a consultant psychiatrist was appointed as a Single Joint Expert to report to the Court in response to questions from the parties. At the time of the trial the Claimant was detained in a psychiatric unit under the Mental Health Act 1983.
The Court found that an adverse decision in the case, the anticipation of publication and publication itself would give rise to a real and immediate risk of suicide for the purposes of Article 2.
The Court recognized the positive duty of the state under Article 2 to take operational measures to protect an individual whose life is at risk. But it noted that the state had assumed responsibility for the Claimant’s immediate safety through the psychiatric unit and mental-health services, and that the hospital could provide significant protection. The Court had not assumed responsibility for his treatment or safety and in the particular circumstances it was not under a positive duty to prohibit the publications. None of the Strasbourg authorities under Article 2 suggested that a domestic court might be subject to such an obligation in this situation and to find such an obligation would be for the domestic court to create a new principle of Convention law which was something it could not do. See R (Ullah) v Special Adjudicator.
The claim under Article 3 failed for the same reasons and also because the proposed publication by two private media organisations would not constitute treatment by the state within the meaning of Article 3.
In addition there was no proper juridical basis for the injunction application under Articles 2 and 3. Convention rights are ordinarily protected through existing domestic causes of action, see Abassi v Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. The Claimant had not relied on any such cause of action. The Claimant relied on the line of authority flowing from Venables v News Group Newspapers Ltd in which the courts had granted contra mundum injunctions under Articles 2/3 to protect the confidential identity of a person for whom the state had assumed responsibility. But this did not apply in this case where the Court was asked to determine the rights of private parties.
The claim under Articles 2 and 3 failed, in the alternative, on the facts. The positive obligation only required the state to take reasonable steps to protect those rights, and it did so through state psychiatric services.
The claim under Article 8 also failed for the lack of any proper juridical basis. Article 8 does not create a free-standing cause of action by which one person may restrain another. It also failed, in the alternative, on the facts. The Defendants’ journalistic Article 10 rights had to be balanced against the Article 8 rights asserted by the Claimant. Any interference with those rights was outweighed by the Defendants’ rights to publish and the rights of the women contributors to tell their stories, in particular given the contribution the publications would make to a debate of general importance.
The Judge granted permission to appeal on the basis that the importance of the issues raised deserved appellate consideration.
Sara Mansoori KC, Ian Helme and Mannat Malhi appeared for the Claimant. Gavin Millar KC and Ben Silverstone appeared for the Defendants, instructed by Wiggin LLP.
The judgment can be found here.