Hayley Webster, instructed by Edwards Duthie Shamash Solicitors, acted for a Defendant in a successful application to strike out a slander claim arising from six statements made by the Defendant during a closed business meeting. After the Defendant was dismissed for gross misconduct, the Claimant company brought a defamation claim arguing that the statements were defamatory and had caused the company serious financial loss.
Master Sullivan held that only two out of the six statements referred to the Claimant company and struck out four of the statements for lack of reference.
Master Sullivan also held that none of the statements were defamatory of the Claimant, and struck out the claim in its entirety. The statements were merely discourteous and not sufficiently serious to be considered defamatory. Master Sullivan also held that allowing the case to continue would unjustly interfere with the Defendant’s rights to free expression under Article 10.
Click here to read the case commentary from Edwards Duthie Shamash Solicitors.