Court: Magistrates' Court

No bars to extradition and no human rights issues

The Government of the United States of America v Giese

The USA Government sought the extradition of the defendant as he was wanted to stand trial on nineteen counts of serious sexual offences. The case was not a question of doubting the good faith of the US officials who provided the assurance that the defendant would not face an order for civil commitment, but rather the enforceability of the assurance in the future. The Court held that there were no bars to extradition and no human rights issues.

Court considers human rights risks in extradition case

Turkey v Nurhak Talay

Turkey sought the extradition of the claimant for “Terrorist” related offences. The Court, inter alia, considered whether there was an abuse of process, and any risk of breach of the ECHR, arts 2, 3, 6 and 8. Mark Summers QC and Aaron Watkins were involved in this case.

US extradition request for defendant charged with electronic stock market manipulation was valid

Government of the United States of America v Sarao

The requesting state sought extradition of the defendant to face trial for electronically manipulating the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, which allegedly led the market to fall or climb to the value of $40 million. The defendant argued that crimes which he was accused of were not offences in the UK, and that if a trial was necessary, it was in the interests of justice for it to occur in this jurisdiction. He also argued that the extradition would infringe ECHR, art 8 and that the US request was an abuse of process, because it was premised on a materially misleading factual basis. Held: The extradition request was valid.

Climate change protestors given suspended sentences and escape prison

CPS v Basto & Ors

The ‘Heathrow 13’ avoided being imprisoned for trespassing at Heathrow Airport, after protesting the possible expansion of the airport. The individuals received six week sentences, suspended for 12 months. The judge handing down the sentence remarked that they were all of good character with a long standing commitment to climate change, genuinely acting in the […]